TheBrain wrote : In my opinion, there is nothing real about that expectation. If the majority of responses the creator gets here are 'great game!' that leaves little incentive for him to change what he's doing despite the early stage of development.
All I'm saying is that criticism is not exclusive from appreciation, as long as you stay polite.
I do believe that without change this game will end up in mediocrity together with the vast majority of games in this genre.
You are making valid points, but what games would you say are currently
above this mediocrity?
I have browsed around an awful lot of games sites. Most of them have small short games which are all very similar.
I suppose I enjoyed the Booty Call series most before I discovered Shark's stuff here, and then Pusooy.
Now I am an oldie with very little software techno knowledge, and so I have no idea how much effort and work is put into these things.
I really like Shark's ideas and the 'mechanics' of his games, but I think Pusooy's images/artwork are better, or look more realistic - so ideally a combination of the two would be the answer.
I also like Ariane very much - again because the images are very good, and there is a certain challenge in the exploration.
Thus I like what chaotic has done here.
He obviously has plans for expansion, as there are two other girls showing already.
Yes it has very similar locations/scenarios to Ariane, but as has been rightly pointed out, it is hard to be totally original in this genre.
I think you are mainly suggesting that it should be more of a labyrinth of a game - with more paths, and end results.
I agree, but I would guess that makes it proportionately more complicated to produce, and requires more images.
As to Chaotic having his ego satisfied by the praise, I doubt it. I would hope it has the opposite effect and encourage him to get the two other girls up and 'working', and add and increase the paths and routes in Crystal.
What we may be able to help with is trying to suggest new scenarios or ways of expanding the game.
We have had one question already, about the hotel receptionist? There's an opportunity - Chaotic has shown his abilities with Rachel, so why not have an 'opportunity' to meet the receptionist or even the greeter, again when Crystal returns from the Mall, Bar and Stripjoint?
Why not add another chance in the casino, winning more money, and maybe taking these other girls back to the room with Crystal and champagne .....................
The party side of things already has the first and bigger jacuzzi under used ....... something could happen with other guests.
After the pose-off, Izzi being the loser, could become Crystal's slave, or in fact the loser either way could become the other's slave.
Again the room Crystal gets for winning could be used in more ways.
Rachel could get invited there somehow, Izzi could be taken there too, or it could become Izzi's room if she won, with her taking/leading Crystal there.
There are also opportunities in Crystal's apartment.
The 'corner' click shows something was planned for the little closet - choice of outfits to wear perhaps?
I'd certainly like to see Crystal in the black dress you buy for her, a bit more, and that would mean she could wear the black lingerie set with the stockings - she says she doesn't wear dresses - that should change.
Anyway I have gone on long enough - I suppose I think it is a good game, and I don't think the term 'mediocrity' should be associated with it.
The ideal I think is that you may get and ending, but you are never sure that you have seen every ending. That will encourage people to carry on playing, always searching for new combinations of events.
Maybe there is one 'route' that will allow you to get Crystal, Rachel, Izzi, the Receptionist, and the Greeter having a six-some on the sofa in Crystal's apartment .......