I played your game and it was good for a first game.
I agree with most of the other commentors.
It needs more depth and you need some kind of feedback in the characters responses to let the player know they have chosen the right or wrong choice.
Like a lot of Them I also encourage you to keep going.
I know it can be difficult to get the idea you want across to the public but as you do more an more games you will find it easier and easier.
I really like the sound of your next game and if you keep true to what you have said, basing your characters off real girls you have had a crush on I think they will be much better developed characters.
This will improve a lot on your first game.
Welcome aboard it's great to have another game creator getting involved.
Our little community is growing quite fast it's good to be a part of such a great and helpful community.
Like others have said in the end if you are happy with the game then it's a success.
Thanks for putting me in your list of muses.

Hopefully soon I'll have more to give the community.
I have recently teamed up with ExtraStiffy he is helping me with the writing of Uni Dreams.
Cheers
Sy